Second Date Update: Noah & April (Don’t Take Me Out To The Ballgame) sarahmac | January 2, 2026 | Brooke & Jeffrey Second Date Update Jan 2, 2026 Photo: nicoletaionescu / iStock / Getty Images The guy in today’s Second Date Update made a BOLD REQUEST before we even called his date. Was it fair? Sure! Was Brooke offended by it? Yep! Previous Next
Photo: nicoletaionescu / iStock / Getty Images The guy in today’s Second Date Update made a BOLD REQUEST before we even called his date. Was it fair? Sure! Was Brooke offended by it? Yep!
